A federal appeals court on November 13 set aside a Transportation Department decision that withheld $73.5 million in highway funding from New York over how long the state’s commercial driver’s licenses for noncitizens stayed valid.
A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit granted New York’s petition in New York v. Department of Transportation, No. 26-1097. Judge Alison Nathan wrote the opinion, joined by Judge Sarah Merriam. Judge Schwartz agreed with the result in a separate opinion.
Why the agency cut New York’s funding
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration reviewed New York’s licensing program in 2025. It concluded the state had issued “non-domiciled” CDLs, licenses for drivers who live in the U.S. but are citizens of other countries, that stayed valid after the drivers’ immigration documents expired. In a sample of 200 such licenses and learner’s permits, the agency said 101 remained valid past those dates.
In an April 2026 final determination, the agency found New York substantially out of compliance and withheld 4 percent of the state’s federal-aid highway funds for fiscal 2027, or $73,502,543. It warned that continued noncompliance could double the cut to about $147 million. It had also told New York to pause issuing these licenses and to void noncompliant ones.
New York had about 32,600 non-domiciled CDL and permit holders as of July 2025, about 7 percent of the state’s total. Holders include Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA)A policy begun in 2012 under which certain people who came to the United States as children could request deferred action, a discretionary decision not to pursue removal for a set period, along with work authorization. Deferred action does not provide lawful status. Under current court orders, USCIS continues to process renewals but is not approving initial requests.See it in the glossary recipients, asylees and RefugeeA person outside their country of nationality who cannot return because of persecution or a well-founded fear of persecution based on race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group or political opinion (INA 101(a)(42)). Admission as a refugee is discretionary, and annual admission levels are set through a Presidential Determination. A person already in the United States or at a port of entry with a similar claim may instead seek asylum.See it in the glossary. The state issued them for the same five-year and eight-year terms as other commercial licenses.
Why the Second Circuit sided with New York
The court held that the federal rules in force before September 2025 contained no requirement to match a license’s expiration date to a driver’s immigration paperwork, and noted the agency itself conceded the text did not say so. The agency could not withhold funding over “a regulatory requirement that did not exist,” Nathan wrote.
The opinion said the old rules required states to check immigration status only when issuing, renewing, upgrading or transferring a license. It added that work permits and foreign passports do not reliably show how long a person may lawfully stay, since an EAD (Employment Authorization Document)A card issued by USCIS on Form I-765 that allows certain noncitizens to work legally while another application is pending or a status permits it.See it in the glossary reflects work permission, not lawful presence.
The court also found that the agency had considered and rejected a similar matching requirement, suggested by states such as Michigan, when it wrote the rules in 2011, and had never before penalized a state on that basis. Schwartz said the plain text alone decided the case and the majority should not have gone on to discuss regulatory history.
The new federal CDL rule still applies
The decision addresses only the rules in place before the agency changed them. An interim rule in September 2025 and a Final ruleThe version of a federal regulation that an agency publishes in the Federal Register after reviewing public comments on a proposed rule. It sets an effective date, which generally falls at least 30 days after publication, and its text is added to the Code of Federal Regulations.See it in the glossary effective March 16, 2026, now cap a non-domiciled CDL at the expiration date on the driver’s I-94The Arrival/Departure Record that U.S. Customs and Border Protection creates when a nonimmigrant is admitted. It shows the class of admission and an Admit Until date, and most are now electronic and available on the CBP I-94 website. USCIS can also issue one when it approves an extension of stay or a change of status.See it in the glossary record or one year, whichever is sooner, and require proof of lawful immigration status.
The Second Circuit said it expressed no view on those newer rules, which face separate litigation in the D.C. Circuit. That court declined in May to pause the final rule while the challenge proceeds.
The case is one of several clashes between federal agencies and states over immigration-related conditions. For why courts often set aside agency actions, see why federal courts keep blocking immigration rules. For how work permits differ by category, see asylum-based work authorization vs. other EADs.
