Judge Extends Afghan Deportation Block for Five Detainees

A federal judge in New York has barred the government from deporting five detained Afghan nationals to Pakistan, Afghanistan or any other third country. The order replaces a broader temporary block that ran through November 7 and requires a week of notice before any removal.

A federal judge in New York has barred the Trump administration from deporting five detained Afghan nationals to Pakistan, Afghanistan or any other third country, extending and narrowing an emergency order that was due to expire on Saturday, November 7.

U.S. District Judge Victor Marrero, a Clinton appointee, issued the decision on Friday, November 6, in a lawsuit brought by Project Rousseau, Inc., a nonprofit that provides legal services to AsylumProtection granted to a person already in the United States or at a port of entry who meets the definition of a refugee and cannot safely return to their country.See it in the glossary seekers, IANS reported. The order stays in place until the court says otherwise, and the government must tell the court and Project Rousseau of any plan to deport the five at least one week in advance.

What the Afghan deportation order says

Marrero barred removal of the five to Pakistan, Afghanistan “or any other third country pending further order of this Court.” Each of the five has a final order of removal and is held in a detention facility in Texas or Louisiana, according to a declaration filed in the case.

The order does not decide whether the planned removals are lawful, and it does not certify a class. It keeps things as they are for the five people while the case moves forward.

How the case got here

Project Rousseau sued on November 2, naming Acting Immigration and Customs Enforcement Director David J. Venturella, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, Attorney General Todd Blanche and Secretary of State Marco Rubio as defendants. The suit followed court filings showing ICE planned to fly detained Afghans from Louisiana to Pakistan, with onward transport to Afghanistan.

On November 3, U.S. District Judge Valerie Caproni, an Obama appointee, issued a Temporary restraining orderA short-term court order that preserves the status quo until the court can decide a motion for a preliminary injunction. In federal court, one issued without notice to the other side expires within 14 days unless the court extends it for good cause or the other side consents (Fed. R. Civ. P. 65(b)).See it in the glossary holding the government to its statement that no deportation flights to Afghanistan or Pakistan were planned that week, ABC News reported. That order applied to Afghan nationals generally and was set to end at 11:59 p.m. on November 7. TR Immigration covered it in our earlier report.

Marrero, who took over the case, amended and extended the order. He rejected, at this stage, the government’s argument that immigration law strips the court of jurisdiction. He wrote that the suit concerns the procedures the government must follow when it chooses to remove someone to a country not named in the removal order, not a challenge to the removal orders themselves.

Who the new order covers

The amended order covers only the five people identified in the case, not Afghan nationals in detention generally. Earlier reports put the number of Afghans who could face removal on a planned flight at more than 150, Kabul Now reported.

Some of the Afghans facing removal may be relatives of people who worked alongside U.S. forces. For how the special Immigrant visaA visa issued at a consulate to a person intending to live permanently in the United States. On admission the holder becomes a permanent resident.See it in the glossary program for those workers operates, see our guide to Afghan and Iraqi SIVs.

What happens next

The order holds while Project Rousseau amends its complaint and the parties brief a request for a Preliminary injunctionA temporary court order pausing enforcement of a rule or policy while a legal case is still being decided.See it in the glossary, a longer-lasting order. No hearing date had been reported as of November 10. Related court actions and rules are listed on our Policy Tracker.

Share this article