The Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA)The administrative body within the Department of Justice that hears appeals from immigration judges and certain USCIS decisions.See it in the glossary issued two precedent decisions this week, one holding that “Guatemalan women without partners” is not a valid particular social group for AsylumProtection granted to a person already in the United States or at a port of entry who meets the definition of a refugee and cannot safely return to their country.See it in the glossary, and another requiring Immigration judgeAn attorney appointed by the Attorney General who presides over removal proceedings in immigration court, part of the Executive Office for Immigration Review.See it in the glossary to explain how they weigh disputed statements in Bond hearingA hearing in which an immigration judge decides whether a noncitizen detained by DHS may be released from custody and, if so, under what bond. Eligibility depends on which detention law applies to the person, and immigration judges have no authority over bond for some groups, such as those subject to mandatory detention.See it in the glossary.
Both are published precedents, which bind immigration judges across the country.
Matter of A-C-V-M-: the particular social group ruling
In Matter of A-C-V-M-, 30 I&N Dec. 236, decided November 12, an immigration judge had granted asylum in November 2022 to a Guatemalan woman who testified that a man on a motorcycle grabbed her and tried to pull her onto it, and that other men touched her without consent. DHS appealed. The woman, who had no lawyer, did not respond.
Asylum requires persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, political opinion or membership in a particular social group. A social group must share a trait its members cannot change, be defined with particularity and be seen as distinct by the society in question.
Writing for the panel, Appellate Immigration Judge Creppy said the group failed two of those tests. The word “partner” has no fixed meaning, the Board said, and could cover casual dating, a committed relationship, a shared child or marriage, so the group lacks clear boundaries. Nothing in the record showed that Guatemalan society sees these women as a group. The Board agreed with the judge that “Guatemalan women” alone is too broad, citing a 2021 Third Circuit decision and its own 2025 precedent.
The Board also rejected the judge’s finding that the men targeted the woman for an imputed political opinion, her perceived defiance of male-dominated norms. It called that finding speculation and reaffirmed an earlier 2026 precedent holding that a political opinion must relate to the government. An opinion about social conventions alone does not qualify. The Board vacated the asylum grant and ordered her removed to Guatemala.
Matter of G-M-T-: bond hearings and proffers
In Matter of G-M-T-, 30 I&N Dec. 228, decided November 10, an immigration judge in Colorado released a man on a $15,000 bond. DHS appealed, arguing he was a flight risk.
Bond hearings often move quickly, and lawyers commonly present facts by “proffer,” a summary statement rather than sworn testimony. In a decision by Temporary Appellate Immigration Judge Picos, the Board confirmed that judges may rely on proffers. But when the other side offers a competing account, or challenges a proffer as uncorroborated or inconsistent with the record, the judge must address that dispute and explain in the bond memorandum how much weight each account gets.
The judge here had credited the man’s unsupported claim that he had paid taxes since 2012, and his lawyer’s statement that one of his children is a U.S. citizen, even though the lawyer described that child as both a son and a daughter. The judge also counted a pending application for Withholding of removalProtection that bars removal to a particular country where a person's life or freedom would be threatened, or where torture is more likely than not. The judge still issues a removal order, the protection does not lead to a green card, and DHS may be able to remove the person to a third country.See it in the glossary and torture protection in his favor without evidence of its strength.
The Board added that relatives who only offer to “support” a detainee take on no legal obligation, so their letters deserve limited weight. It vacated the bond and sent the case back for a new decision.
What the two BIA decisions mean
A-C-V-M- builds on the Board’s 2025 ruling that groups defined only by sex and nationality are too broad, now applying the same scrutiny to a narrower definition tied to relationship status. G-M-T- makes clear that when DHS contests a fact in a bond hearing, records such as birth certificates, school records and tax returns can matter more than a lawyer’s summary.
Both follow a busy fall of Board precedents, including four decisions on bond, asylum and torture protection and the bond ruling in Matter of M-S-V-. Noncitizens can ask a federal appeals court to review Board decisions through a petition for review. For background on asylum’s protected grounds, see asylum vs. refugee status.
