A federal judge in Boston has struck down the Department of Homeland Security’s Duration of status (D/S)The period of stay for F, J and I nonimmigrants, who are admitted for as long as they maintain their program or activity rather than until a fixed date. It appears as D/S on Form I-94.See it in the glossary rule in its entirety, ruling that it was arbitrary and capricious and that parts of it went beyond what Congress allowed, a decision that keeps the decades-old system for international students, exchange visitors and foreign journalists in place nationwide.
U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV, a George W. Bush appointee, granted summary judgment on November 16, 2026, to a coalition of higher education groups and labor unions in Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security, No. 1:26-cv-13799. His eight-page memorandum and order denied the government’s competing motion, vacated the rule and directed the clerk to enter final judgment for the plaintiffs.
The ruling turns the court’s September postponement into a decision on the merits. The rule, published July 17 and scheduled to start September 15, never took effect.
What the duration of status rule would have changed
Under duration of status, F-1 students and J-1 exchange visitors are admitted for as long as they stay enrolled and follow their program rules, so most Forms I-94The Arrival/Departure Record that U.S. Customs and Border Protection creates when a nonimmigrant is admitted. It shows the class of admission and an Admit Until date, and most are now electronic and available on the CBP I-94 website. USCIS can also issue one when it approves an extension of stay or a change of status.See it in the glossary show “D/S” rather than an end date. The Final ruleThe version of a federal regulation that an agency publishes in the Federal Register after reviewing public comments on a proposed rule. It sets an effective date, which generally falls at least 30 days after publication, and its text is added to the Code of Federal Regulations.See it in the glossary would have replaced that with fixed admission periods tied to program dates and capped at four years.
Anyone needing more time would have had to ask USCIS for an extension of stay. The rule also set fixed admission periods for I visa holders who work for foreign media, and it limited students’ ability to transfer schools, change programs or pursue additional study. Our Visa Library comparison of duration of status and fixed admission lays out the two systems side by side.
Why the judge vacated the rule
Saylor adopted the reasoning of his September 14 order, writing that the issues at summary judgment were virtually identical and that no material facts were in dispute. That order found DHS likely failed to weigh costs and benefits properly, offered fraud and national security rationales that did not support the rule, ignored less burdensome alternatives and did not adequately answer significant public comments.
The new ruling adds one more gap. DHS already tracks students through the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System, known as SEVISThe Student and Exchange Visitor Information System, the DHS database that tracks F, M and J students and exchange visitors and the schools that host them. Designated school officials update each record, issue the Form I-20 or DS-2019, and authorize or recommend work options such as CPT and OPT.See it in the glossary, and has used its records to pursue “pay-to-stay” fraud and to run more than one million students through a federal criminal database. DHS argued that SEVIS is a reporting system, not a way to decide anyone’s status. The judge said the agency never adequately explained how a discretionary renewal after four years in the country would catch fraud better, or why it did not weigh improvements to SEVIS against the rule’s costs.
Limits on what students may study
On the question he left open in September, Saylor ruled that the rule’s limits on academic study exceed DHS’s power under the student visa statute. Those limits would have restricted extended programs such as Ph.D. studies, joint degrees, changes in academic concentration and programs not at a higher level than one a student had already completed.
DHS argued that the Homeland Security Secretary has discretion to define a “course of study.” Relying on a 2022 D.C. Circuit decision that upheld Optional Practical Training (OPT)Temporary work authorization that lets eligible F-1 students work in a job directly related to their field of study. It can be used before or after completing a program, for up to 12 months in total at each education level, and students with certain STEM degrees can apply for a 24-month extension. USCIS grants it on Form I-765 after the school's designated school official recommends it.See it in the glossary, the judge said the executive branch may set the time and conditions of a student’s stay, but limiting which programs a student may pursue is neither. He pointed out that DHS itself acknowledged legitimate same-level degrees, such as an M.B.A. after a law degree, which the rule would have barred. “The statute simply does not grant DHS such broad and open-ended authority,” he wrote.
Vacatur instead of a remand
DHS asked the court to send the rule back to the agency without striking it down. Saylor declined, calling VacaturA court order that cancels an agency rule or action and removes its legal effect. Under the Administrative Procedure Act, 5 U.S.C. 706, courts set aside agency action found to be unlawful, which is traditionally treated as vacatur. Whether vacatur can reach beyond the parties to a case is disputed after Trump v. CASA.See it in the glossary the standard remedy and noting that the existing system has operated for decades and the rule never took effect, so setting it aside would not be disruptive.
What happens next
The government’s pending appeal at the First Circuit concerns the September preliminary order, not this judgment. On November 13, the appeals court agreed to hold that appeal in abeyance until the district court ruled on the merits, according to the plaintiffs’ case page.
DHS can appeal the final judgment and ask for a stay. Neither step suspends the ruling on its own, and as of November 17 no new notice of appeal had been reported.
What the ruling means for students and schools now
For F-1 students, J-1 exchange visitors and I visa journalists, the practical picture is the same as it was before July: duration of status remains the operating framework, and the 60-day F-1 grace period, school transfer rules and program change rules continue as they were. Our explainer on the 60-day grace period covers what that window does and does not protect.
Maintaining status still depends on full-time enrollment, a valid Form I-20 or DS-2019 and accurate SEVIS records. Because the government may still seek appellate review, students with upcoming travel or filings should check current guidance with their designated school official or program sponsor.
