BIA Says Late Reopening Can’t Undo Voluntary Departure Bar

In Matter of Ontiveros-Diaz, the Board of Immigration Appeals held that a motion to reopen filed after the voluntary departure deadline does not lift the 10-year bar on relief, even for an application already filed.

The Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA)The administrative body within the Department of Justice that hears appeals from immigration judges and certain USCIS decisions.See it in the glossary has ruled that a noncitizen who misses a Voluntary departurePermission to leave the United States within a set period, at the person's own expense, instead of being ordered removed. Immigration judges and DHS can grant it, and the person must leave by the deadline the grant sets.See it in the glossary deadline cannot escape the 10-year bar on relief by later asking to reopen the case, even to add new evidence to an application the court already heard.

The decision, Matter of Ontiveros-Diaz, 30 I&N Dec. 222, was issued November 5, 2026, as a published precedent. It binds Immigration judgeAn attorney appointed by the Attorney General who presides over removal proceedings in immigration court, part of the Executive Office for Immigration Review.See it in the glossary nationwide on the same question.

What voluntary departure requires

Voluntary departure lets a person in Removal proceedingsThe formal court process, formerly called deportation, in which the government seeks to remove a noncitizen from the United States.See it in the glossary leave the United States by a set date instead of receiving a removal order. The Board described it as an agreement: the person promises to leave on time, and the government agrees not to enter a removal order.

Breaking that agreement has a cost written into the statute. A person who voluntarily fails to depart within the time allowed becomes ineligible, for 10 years, for “any further relief” under several provisions, including Cancellation of removalA form of relief in which an immigration judge can cancel a removal order (INA 240A). For green card holders it generally requires at least 5 years as a permanent resident, 7 years of continuous residence after admission in any status, and no aggravated felony conviction. For others it generally requires 10 years of continuous physical presence, good moral character, no disqualifying convictions, and exceptional and extremely unusual hardship to a U.S. citizen or permanent resident spouse, parent or child.See it in the glossary and Adjustment of statusThe process of applying for a green card from within the United States, rather than through a consulate abroad. Filed on Form I-485.See it in the glossary. Immigration judges must warn people of this when granting voluntary departure.

The facts of Ontiveros-Diaz

An immigration judge denied Daniel Ontiveros-Diaz’s application for cancellation of removal, finding he had not shown that his U.S. citizen children would suffer “exceptional and extremely unusual hardship” if he were removed. On April 4, 2025, the Board dismissed his appeal and gave him 60 days, until June 3, 2025, to leave voluntarily.

He did not leave. On June 17, 2025, two weeks after the deadline, he filed a Motion to reopenA request asking an immigration judge or the Board of Immigration Appeals to reopen a case after a decision so new facts or evidence can be considered. As a general rule it must be filed within 90 days of the final order, and only one is generally allowed, with exceptions set out in INA 240(c)(7) and the regulations.See it in the glossary with new evidence about his children’s education plans, an autism diagnosis, post-traumatic stress after a dog attack and a heart condition already in the record.

His lawyer argued that the 10-year bar covers only new requests for relief, not more evidence on an application already filed, and that a reopened case is no longer final.

How the BIA ruled on reopening and the 10-year bar

The three-member panel rejected both arguments. Writing for the Board, Appellate Immigration Judge Gemoets said the phrase “any further relief” carries its ordinary meaning and is not limited to new applications. Reopening a case “would not invalidate the respondent’s prior violation,” the decision says, and the Board lacks equitable authority to set the statute aside.

The timing of the motion decided the case. Under a 2008 regulation, a motion to reopen filed before the voluntary departure period runs out automatically ends the voluntary departure grant and its penalties. A motion filed after the deadline has no such effect. The Board also noted that Congress wrote specific exceptions, such as for certain survivors of domestic abuse, and created none for people seeking the same relief again.

As a separate ground, the Board said the new evidence was similar to what the judge had already weighed and would not likely change the outcome, since the children would stay in the United States with their mother.

What the voluntary departure ruling means in practice

The decision reinforces that the voluntary departure deadline, not the later filing, controls. A motion to reopen filed after that date does not pause the clock or erase the penalty. The Board noted one existing limit: a person who did not know of the order, or was physically unable to leave through no fault of their own, has not “voluntarily” failed to depart.

The ruling adds to a run of Board precedents this fall, including the bond decision in Matter of Cruz Aijiaco issued November 2. Federal appeals courts can review it when a noncitizen files a petition for review. For how removal cases move from notice to order, see what immigration court notices mean.

Share this article