The Supreme Court on Monday allowed the Trump administration to resume building border barriers and roads in the Big Bend region of West Texas, including inside Big Bend National Park, by putting a lower court’s order on hold while the government seeks a full review.
In an unsigned per curiam opinion issued November 9 in Mullin v. Friends of the Ruidosa Church, No. 26A560, the Court granted the government’s request to stay a Preliminary injunctionA temporary court order pausing enforcement of a rule or policy while a legal case is still being decided.See it in the glossary from the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson said she would have denied the request. She did not write an opinion.
What the Big Bend border wall order does
The stay lets construction go ahead while the government files a petition for CertiorariA request, called a petition for a writ of certiorari, asking the Supreme Court to review a lower court decision. The Court does not have to take the case and typically does so when it involves an unusually important legal principle or when federal appeals courts have read a law differently. In civil cases the petition generally must be filed within 90 days after judgment.See it in the glossary, a formal request for the Supreme Court to take the case. If the Court denies that petition, the stay ends automatically. If it grants the petition, the stay lasts until the Court decides the case. The lawsuit itself also remains open in El Paso.
The Big Bend Sector, as U.S. Customs and Border Protection defines it, covers 517 miles of the U.S.-Mexico border along the Rio Grande. The sector accounts for about 1.6 percent of migrant apprehensions along the whole border, The Texas Tribune reported, and the administration has awarded $7.5 billion in contracts there for roads, barriers and technology.
The waiver law at the center of the case
Section 102 of the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996 lets the Homeland Security secretary build barriers in areas of high illegal entry and “waive all legal requirements” needed to speed construction. The same law allows only constitutional claims against those waivers, bars all other claims, and sends appeals directly to the Supreme Court rather than to a federal appeals court.
Earlier this year, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin found the Big Bend Sector to be an area of high illegal entry and waived a range of environmental and conservation laws there. The plaintiffs, a river guide, the Center for Biological Diversity and a group that preserves a historic church in Ruidosa, Texas, sued in April. Their group says the waivers covered the Endangered Species Act, the Wild and Scenic Rivers Act and the National Park Service Organic Act, and were the first broad waivers of environmental laws inside a national park.
U.S. District Judge Kathleen Cardone, a George W. Bush appointee, blocked the waivers and all related construction on October 2. She found the plaintiffs likely to win on a claim that the waivers violated the major questions doctrine, which she treated as a constitutional rule grounded in the separation of powers.
Why the Supreme Court ruled for the government
The Court said the government is “exceedingly likely to prevail” on its argument that Cardone lacked jurisdiction. However the claim was labeled, it alleged that the secretary exceeded his statutory authority, and such claims are not constitutional ones under the Court’s precedent. “There is no such thing as a ‘constitutional’ major-questions claim,” the opinion says.
On the other factors, the Court cited a CBP declaration that the injunction was costing the government nearly half a million dollars a day that could not be recovered. It said Congress, by allowing waivers of environmental laws, had already chosen speedy border construction over the harms the plaintiffs described, so the government’s interest “outweighs any aesthetic, recreational, and environmental harm.”
What comes next
The Center for Biological Diversity called the decision “horrific,” the Tribune reported. Texas Land Commissioner Dawn Buckingham has separately sent a cease-and-desist letter to CBP and its contractor over alleged clearing of state land in Presidio County. The plaintiffs’ case is one of six lawsuits seeking to stop the Big Bend project.
The ruling is the latest emergency order in the administration’s favor on immigration enforcement, after the Court allowed third-country removals to resume in September. The Court is also set to hear a no-bond detention case this term.
